Inkjet Printer Forum / Ink Jet Refill Forum

Everything you need to know about inkjet printers, ink jet refills, and inkjet cartridges!

You are not logged in.

#1 09/01/2011 1:24:09 am

panos
InkJet Master
From: Greece
Registered: 04/14/2005
Posts: 617

Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

Tom's hardware has published an interesting article with advice for evaluating the quality of your ink and paper. The ink part is obviously focused on refillers which makes it more interesting.

They had also published a comparison of inkjet papers a few months ago. This is a very interesting read as well, I can tell from personal experience that if you print text documents on your inkjet, you'll be blown away by the results on a higher quality paper such as HP Bright White.


“Souls dwell in printer's type” - Joseph Ames

Offline

 

#2 09/01/2011 11:54:11 pm

rodbam
InkJet Master
From: Australia
Registered: 03/08/2011
Posts: 542
Website

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

Thanks for posting the links mate the first one on the inks I found really helpful & some simple ways to test the quality of the inks. There was some great information in the article.


Regards Rod

Canon Pro 9000 mk2 & Pro 9500 mk2. Image Specialist ink refills.

Offline

 

#3 09/02/2011 5:39:09 am

The Hat
InkJet Master
From: Ireland
Registered: 01/18/2010
Posts: 3221
Website

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

I take most of these articles on comparisons and evaluations on paper / ink with extreme caution.
Some have an axe to grind or are in someone’s pocket so try your own tests
on paper you like to use and then draw your own conclusions.

A lot of the time the oddest of papers work great with 3 party inks so finding the right combination
is not always easy and the high profile papers (in everyday use) can turn out to be a bit of a disappointment altogether...


ONLY OEM Carts: (Top filling.) i865 /iP4500 /iP4700 /iX 4000 /i9950. My Own Refill Method for PGI-9 / PGI-29 for iX7000, 9500 II & Pro 1.
Pigment & Dye inks By:-Precisioncolors/Octoinkjet.co.uk. + both KMP great Pigment Blacks
A4 Mono Lasers all OEM Toner & Carts:- Brother HL 1240 /Samsung ML 1450 / Samsung ML 1660.

Offline

 

#4 09/02/2011 7:42:49 pm

rodbam
InkJet Master
From: Australia
Registered: 03/08/2011
Posts: 542
Website

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

Caution is always required but the in depth explanations & magnified views of inks on paper & even the bleed test putting a drop of ink into another colour is easy to do at home but whether this indicates a true quality ink I don't know.
I learnt a lot more reading that article than from any other I've read & they didn't rubbish aftermarket inks, just a caution to find a good quality one which is the advice given here.
I've found I get very good looking prints from photocopy paper, cheap Kodak papers (I use this paper for test prints) & just love the prints I make on Ilfords smooth pearl.
We get very little choice down here in Oz to find a good cheap paper.


Regards Rod

Canon Pro 9000 mk2 & Pro 9500 mk2. Image Specialist ink refills.

Offline

 

#5 09/03/2011 7:18:31 am

The Hat
InkJet Master
From: Ireland
Registered: 01/18/2010
Posts: 3221
Website

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

I've found I get very good looking prints from photocopy paper, cheap Kodak papers (I use this paper for test prints) & just love the prints I make on Ilfords smooth pearl. We get very little choice down here in Oz to find a good cheap paper.

That’s it rodbam just keep on the lookout for any paper and try every sample you can get your hands on
as expensive papers are not always the best as they tend to be aimed at specific markets (most profitable)..smile


ONLY OEM Carts: (Top filling.) i865 /iP4500 /iP4700 /iX 4000 /i9950. My Own Refill Method for PGI-9 / PGI-29 for iX7000, 9500 II & Pro 1.
Pigment & Dye inks By:-Precisioncolors/Octoinkjet.co.uk. + both KMP great Pigment Blacks
A4 Mono Lasers all OEM Toner & Carts:- Brother HL 1240 /Samsung ML 1450 / Samsung ML 1660.

Offline

 

#6 09/03/2011 9:17:02 am

panos
InkJet Master
From: Greece
Registered: 04/14/2005
Posts: 617

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

rodbam wrote:

they didn't rubbish aftermarket inks

That's the reason they got my attention. Most articles about printer inks in mass media publications are just trashing the aftermarket vendors.

This one didn't.

In regards to papers, I have found that while ink/paper combinations can vary greatly in photos (eg. HP photo papers would provide terrible results when combined with my aftermarket Canon inks), text and graphics printed in normal papers (up to 90g) are not affected by the specific combination of ink and paper as much as they are affected by the qualities of ink and paper separately.

For example I have used HP's bright white for many years with excellent results in both HP and Canon printers using either OEM ink or various aftermarket brands. The only problem is that HP Bright White isn't a two sided paper, only one side is treated to provide the best results.

On the other hand, I sometimes use an extremely cheap brand of plain paper that always yields bad results no matter the ink or the printer.

I think articles such as Tom's that increase the public's awareness of the importance of paper are good steps to the right direction.


“Souls dwell in printer's type” - Joseph Ames

Offline

 

#7 09/03/2011 1:52:16 pm

stratman
InkJet Master
From: USA
Registered: 04/19/2007
Posts: 1798

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

Fun couple of articles with solid basic information.  Thanks for the links.

But a couple of statements that maybe got lost in translation...

From the May 26 article:

You can’t calibrate a printer, but you can calibrate a monitor.

Forum members must be a brilliant and powerful lot to bend space and time with their printer profiles.  No wonder Grandad35 goes around telling people to "kneel before Zod".  bow  gig

I picked up a ream of the HP Multipurpose paper to evaluate the ColorLok function based on forum members' posts.  The results of TomsHardware tests appear to substantiate what forum members said.  Maybe we are a brilliant and powerful group.  woot


From the September 1 article:

The subject of printing has the potential to be super boring.

Not at all.  tongue

Isn't it odd that in a world where everything seems to be stored in digital form, we still wind up printing so much content to paper?

Umm, no again, but I get the popular point he's trying to make.  Technology isn't capable of being paperless for several reasons and humans still like the experience of using paper.  What is odd is Soylent Green  is ******!  duc  (Censored so as to not ruin the movie for those who have not seen it.  It's a good sci-fi flick about the year 2022, which was 50 years into the future from when the movie was made.)

Offline

 

#8 09/03/2011 7:31:37 pm

rodbam
InkJet Master
From: Australia
Registered: 03/08/2011
Posts: 542
Website

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

Stratman are you saying we calibrate a printer?


Regards Rod

Canon Pro 9000 mk2 & Pro 9500 mk2. Image Specialist ink refills.

Offline

 

#9 09/03/2011 8:53:08 pm

stratman
InkJet Master
From: USA
Registered: 04/19/2007
Posts: 1798

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

Yes, Rodham, via ICM profiles.  Even the manufacturer gives you basic calibration tools in their software such as the Properties settings found in Canon software.

I thought you Aussies were infamous for sarcasm.  Maybe your not getting your daily recommended amount of beer.  droolin

Offline

 

#10 09/04/2011 12:06:46 am

rodbam
InkJet Master
From: Australia
Registered: 03/08/2011
Posts: 542
Website

Re: Tom's Hardware ink evaluation & paper benchmarks

Ah I thought you were calling profiling calibration. Well we are infamous for what you call sarcasm ( sarcasm to us means vindictive or hateful type jokes)  Ours is more Irony/satire I spose but why I missed yours was the absence of swear words:-)


Regards Rod

Canon Pro 9000 mk2 & Pro 9500 mk2. Image Specialist ink refills.

Offline

 

Board footer

Show recent posts

© Copyright Nifty-Stuff.com

[ Generated in 0.076 seconds, 13 queries executed ]